Probably a 3.5 for me. This one was so much more than the menage. It really explored the emotions of the 3 involved, especially Trevor and Ed. They got closure (or lack of a better word) and so much more. I really enjoyed Chassie she's a firecracker and it would take one heck of a woman to make that situation work. Good for her. Glad we got to see Colt some, I'm looking forward to his book. Love those McKays!